ACR Roofing website

ACR Roofing

Trading name of ACR ROOFING PTY LTD · Melbourne, VIC

★★★★★ 4.7 · 63 Google reviews
✓ Verified business · ABN active 23 yrs

AustralianRoofers Trust Score New

90
out of 100
Excellent
✓
Verified identityABN active on the public register
25/25
✓
LongevityRegistered company ≈23 yrs
20/20
✓
Review reputation4.7★ across 63 Google reviews
33/35
✓
Cross-source consistencyno independent second-source rating found — single-source reputation
12/20

How it's calculated: a transparent, evidence-weighted score — identity & longevity from the public ABN register, reputation from verified Google reviews, and consistency from cross-checking independent platforms. Grades are proportional to the evidence. Where we search the register and can't confirm a business, the identity check scores zero rather than being quietly left out — so a firm we couldn't verify never outranks one we could. Longevity stays unscored in that case, because without a registration date there's nothing to measure.

Our honest take

Verdict: Long-running commercial re-roofing specialist, with two disputes to weigh

If a mate who owned a factory or managed a row of shops asked us about ACR Roofing, we'd say it's one of the more clearly specialised outfits among the Melbourne roofers we've reviewed. This is not a general roofer. Its own website says it only replaces existing asbestos and metal roofs, and the Google reviews bear that out: a whole factory roof, an asbestos roof swapped for metal on an industrial building in Northcote, new translucent sheeting across a 6,000 square metre manufacturing facility, a Blackburn shop whose roofing job was done over the Easter break so the tenants never had to stop trading. One customer says the team 'operate like a well-oiled machine'; another that they 'stuck to their quote like glue'.

The paperwork checks out. The ABN printed on the firm's own site belongs to ACR Roofing Pty Ltd, an active company registered in April 2003 in Moorabbin's postcode. On its site the firm says the business started in 1982 and was sold in 2008 to Jay, Paul and Christian, who still run it — that's the firm's own history, and the register can only vouch for the company from 2003. The site also lists a plumbing-industry licence number and an asbestos licence number. We haven't checked those against the regulators' registers, so ask for them and look them up yourself.

Now the part you need to read before you sign. The rating is 4.7 from 63, and four of the 20 most recent reviews are one-star. Two of those aren't from customers at all: one is about a driver's behaviour in Box Hill, the other from a neighbouring business that says the crew filled its bin with rubbish. The other two are from clients. A 2023 reviewer says the job ran far over time, communication was poor and building permits weren't applied for; there's no reply from the firm on record. A 2024 reviewer alleges poor communication, asbestos stored in an unauthorised area, leaks, and $30,000 of extra cost blamed on the firm's poor coordination with other trades. The firm answered that one at length, calling the asbestos claim 'completely false' and saying the other trades were organised by the client. We can't tell you who is right. What we can say is that every review since April 2025 — seven of them — is five-star.

Reputation across the web New

The same firm, checked across platforms

Google
★ 4.7 /5
63 reviews
Primary source · verified place
independently pulled
Second source
No independent second-source listing found yet. The score reflects single-source reputation and says so.
How we read this: Google is the only real review source here: 4.7 from 63, with 15 five-star, one four-star and four one-star among the 20 most recent. There's no ProductReview listing. So there's no independent second opinion to check it against.

⚑ Two client complaints about communication and project management — one still disputed

Among ACR Roofing's 20 most recent Google reviews are two one-star accounts from paying clients. One (2023) says the job ran far over time, communication was poor and building permits weren't applied for; there is no public reply from the firm. The other (2024) alleges asbestos was stored in an unauthorised area, leaks appeared, and poor coordination with other trades cost an extra $30,000; the firm's public reply rejects this, calls the asbestos claim 'completely false' and says the other trades were arranged by the client. We can't judge who is right, and 15 of the same 20 reviews are five-star. But both complaints turn on the same things, so settle them in writing before work starts: the programme, who applies for permits, where asbestos will be stored, and who coordinates any other trades.

Verified business details New

Checked against the public ABN register

ABN
45 104 549 966 · Active
ACN
104 549 966
Registered
Apr 2003 · ~23 yrs
GST
Registered · since 2008
Entity type
Australian Private Company
Registered name
ACR ROOFING PTY LTD
Location
VIC 3189

Source: verified against the official Australian Business Register via ABN Lookup (abr.business.gov.au), including GST registration.

Why we bother: "years in business" is the claim most roofers make and fewest prove. The register settles it — an established registered company is a materially different risk to a brand-new sole trader, and now you don't have to take anyone's word for it.

What they're actually known for New

Ranked by what customers mention — not a self-declared list

Re-roofing / full replacement6 of 20 reviews
Leak detection & repair1 of 20 reviews
Metal & Colorbond1 of 20 reviews
Guttering & downpipes1 of 20 reviews
Skylights1 of 20 reviews
What this tells us: Re-roofing dominates the review taxonomy — six mentions, against one each for leaks, metal and Colorbond, guttering and skylights. Those are small counts, so treat them as light evidence, but they line up with what the firm says about itself: it replaces existing asbestos and metal roofs and wall cladding, mostly on commercial and industrial buildings. The single 'skylight' mention is translucent sheeting on a factory, and the single 'leak' mention comes from a complaint. On its own site the firm says it does not do tiled or slate roofs, roof repairs, cleaning, re-pointing or painting.

Who you'll actually deal with

Jay, Paul and Christian — owners since 2008, by the firm's own account

The firm's about page tells the story in some detail: founded in 1982 by Trevor McDonald and Ian Martin, run for years by Ian and his wife Carol, then sold in 2008 to their son Jay and two long-time colleagues, Paul and Christian. That is the firm's own account, but the reviews show the same names at work. One property manager credits 'Jay and his team' with handling council permits and CitiPower requirements on a Richmond job, another gives a 'special mention to Ray, Paul and Jay' on a project involving airport regulators, and a 2026 reviewer thanks Christian by name. Ray turns up in two separate reviews as well, though his role isn't stated.

This is a company with an office and crews, not an owner-operator on the tools. The owner replies on Google are mostly signed 'The ACR Roofing Team', and the site says all its roof plumbers are licensed asbestos removalists and that it trains apprentices — again, the firm's own claims. One practical point from the critical reviews: a client complained that the owner was away on holiday during a key stage of their job. On a large project, ask who your day-to-day contact will be and who decides things if that person is unavailable.

What clients say

In their own words

★★★★★

The team was awesome for an intermediate size project I had to replace some supersix in Abbotsford. They stuck to their quote like glue, which was very impressive. Timing was great and the final roof looks amazing. I'd recommend them and use them again without hesitation.

— Shannon M

Most reviewers are commercial property owners and managers describing asbestos and metal roof replacements delivered on budget and worked around trading tenants; the four one-star reviews in the latest 20 are two client complaints about communication and project management and two from non-customers.

Best for

  • Owners and managers of factories, warehouses and shops who need an existing asbestos or metal roof removed and replaced
  • Jobs that have to be staged around tenants who keep trading — reviewers describe an Easter-break job and works planned so a business could keep running
  • Projects with paperwork attached — reviews mention help with council permits, power company requirements, tenants and real estate agents

Less suited for

  • Homeowners with tiled or slate roofs, or anyone wanting repairs, cleaning, re-pointing or painting — the firm's own site says it doesn't offer these
  • Small leak fixes and urgent call-outs — this is a quote-and-programme replacement contractor, and the reviews are almost all large projects
  • Multi-trade projects with nobody in overall charge — the one disputed complaint turned on who was responsible for coordinating other trades on the roof

Before you commit

Five questions worth asking

  • Can you confirm the plumbing licence and asbestos removal licence numbers shown on your website, and send a current public liability certificate, so I can check them before signing?
  • Who will be my day-to-day contact for the whole job, and who makes decisions if that person is away?
  • Who applies for the building permit and deals with the power company, and is that written into the quote with dates?
  • Where will removed asbestos be kept on site before disposal, and how will tenants and neighbours be told?
  • Your site mentions fixed-price quotes and an additional ACR Roofing warranty alongside the BlueScope manufacturer's warranty — can I have both in writing, including what happens if other trades work on the roof afterwards?

Bottom line

A verified, long-established Moorabbin company that does one thing — replacing asbestos and metal roofs on commercial buildings — and has a run of detailed, happy reviews from the people who commission that work. Two client complaints about communication and project management are on the record, one of them still disputed, so get the programme, permits, asbestos handling and trade coordination in writing. If you have a tiled house roof or a small repair, this isn't your firm.

Assessed by the editorial team at AustralianRoofers.com from public Google Business Profile data, the firm's own website, and the ABN register. Payment never influences this assessment.

Contact ACR Roofing

This firm hasn't published an enquiry email we can verify, so the quickest way to reach them is by phone or through their Google profile.