AustralianRoofers Trust Score New
How it's calculated: a transparent, evidence-weighted score — identity & longevity from the public ABN register, reputation from verified Google reviews, and consistency from cross-checking independent platforms. Grades are proportional to the evidence. Where we search the register and can't confirm a business, the identity check scores zero rather than being quietly left out — so a firm we couldn't verify never outranks one we could. Longevity stays unscored in that case, because without a registration date there's nothing to measure.
Our honest take
If a mate in Melbourne's outer east asked us about ELR Roofing, we'd say it has one of the stronger records among the Melbourne roofers we've reviewed. It holds 4.9 from 220 Google reviews, and the 20 most recent — nineteen 5-stars and one happy 4-star — are unusually detailed. They describe real, sizeable jobs: tile roofs replaced with Colorbond, a leaking 30-year-old skillion roof replaced within the week that was promised, a complex re-roof with extra skylights and an evaporative cooler removed, and a full roof replacement on a 12-apartment building in St Kilda, written up at length by the chair of its owners corporation. The same things come up again and again — punctual crews, clear communication, a tidy site — and more than one customer says ELR's quote was the best of several they received.
We checked the Australian Business Register and found an exact match: ELR Roofing Pty Ltd, ABN 21 641 718 710, an active, GST-registered Victorian company registered in June 2020, which also holds the business name ELR Roof Plumbing. On its own site the firm names Taylor Waterworth as founder and managing director and describes him as a licensed and qualified roof plumber; it also says the team is fully licensed and insured and offers 'comprehensive guarantees on work and materials'. Those are the firm's claims — the site doesn't publish a licence number or the guarantee terms — but the reviews back up the picture of who's in charge: Taylor is named in 12 of the 20 most recent reviews, usually alongside Peter.
The caveats are small ones. This is a Colorbond and metal re-roofing business first, so if you have a tiled roof you'd like restored rather than replaced, the recent reviews don't show ELR doing that. The site's experience claims don't quite agree with each other — 'over 15 years of business in the roofing industry' in one place, 'over a decade' in another, eight years for Taylor personally — and all of them sit against a company registered in 2020. Older reviews call the firm 'ELR Plumbing', so the people may well predate the Pty Ltd, but the company you'd sign with is six years old. Our research found no ProductReview listing, so Google is the only place its reviews can be read. Lastly, we've read only the 20 most recent reviews in full; a 4.9 across 220 means there are a few lower ratings further back that we haven't seen.
Reputation across the web New
The same firm, checked across platforms
Verified business details New
Checked against the public ABN register
Source: verified against the official Australian Business Register via ABN Lookup (abr.business.gov.au), including GST registration.
What they're actually known for New
Ranked by what customers mention — not a self-declared list
Who you'll actually deal with
Taylor Waterworth — founder and managing director, with Peter alongside
The firm's own about page names Taylor Waterworth as founder and managing director, describes him as a licensed and qualified roof plumber, and says he'll be your main point of contact from first call to completion. The reviews bear that out: Taylor is named in 12 of the 20 most recent — quoting, scheduling, explaining variations and checking in during the job — and the owners corporation chair who oversaw a 12-apartment re-roof in St Kilda credits him personally with coordinating permits, trades and tenants. We haven't seen the licence ourselves, so ask for the number.
Peter (sometimes Pete) is the other name that keeps turning up, in 9 of the 20 — often with Taylor on re-roofs, and leading repair and gutter jobs himself, including a leak repair where he showed the customer before-and-after photos of the work. One customer says both men were on site every day of their re-roof. Reviewers also thank a wider crew and describe other trades being organised for them — solar panel removal and refitting, for instance — so this is a small company with a team rather than a one-man band. The reviews don't give Peter's role or surname, so we won't guess.
What clients say
In their own words
The team at ELR Roofing did a great job reroofing and installing roof blanket on my house. The roofers where very pleasant to talk to any request was no problem and happily dealt with. Great bunch of guys and highly recommend them for roofing work.
We had a leak around our Chimney which needed some quick attention. I called ELR and was helped by the team there. They were able to get the job done quickly and at a good price . Quality of work was great ! Thanks team!
ELR replaced all the guttering around our house in a speedy and efficient way. Their attention to detail was exceptional. They were professional and courteous at all times and very easy to deal with. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend ELR.
Recent reviewers describe well-organised Colorbond re-roofs and tidy repair and gutter jobs: crews that turn up when promised, Taylor keeping customers informed, competitive quotes and clean sites — with nothing critical in the 20 most recent reviews.
Best for
- Tile-to-Colorbond conversions and full metal re-roofs in Melbourne's outer east and south-east — the bulk of what recent reviewers describe
- Complicated re-roofs that need other trades coordinated — reviewers mention solar panels, skylights, insulation and, in one case, a 12-apartment building managed through its owners corporation
- Factory and warehouse roof replacements, which the firm lists as a core service and which several Google reviews shown on its site describe
Less suited for
- Tile roof restorations — re-bedding, re-pointing and repainting — which don't feature in the recent reviews; this is a metal-roofing business first
- Anyone who wants a second, independent review platform — there's no ProductReview listing, so Google is the only source
- Homeowners a long way from the east and south-east — the firm says it services all of Melbourne, but it's based in Lilydale and its suburb pages cluster in the east, south-east and Yarra Valley, so ask about lead times
Before you commit
Five questions worth asking
- Your site says Taylor is a licensed roof plumber and the team is fully licensed and insured — can you give me the Victorian licence or registration number and a current insurance certificate so I can check them?
- Your ABN isn't on your website — can you confirm the quote and contract will be with ELR Roofing Pty Ltd, ABN 21 641 718 710?
- Your site mentions 'comprehensive guarantees on work and materials' — what are the terms and lengths, in writing, for the workmanship and for the Colorbond itself?
- Does the quote cover everything a re-roof needs — safety rails or scaffolding, skips, insulation, solar panel removal and refitting — and how will you price anything unexpected once the old roof is off?
- Who will run my job day to day — Taylor, Peter or someone else — and what's your current lead time to start?
Bottom line
A registered six-year-old company with one of the deeper review records in Melbourne's outer east — 4.9 from 220 — and recent reviews that describe big Colorbond re-roofs handled on time, with good communication from the owner. The gaps are minor: no independent second review source, and experience claims on the site that outrun the company's 2020 registration. Confirm the licence, insurance and guarantee in writing, and for a metal re-roof this is a firm we'd happily get a quote from.
Assessed by the editorial team at AustralianRoofers.com from public Google Business Profile data, the firm's own website, and the ABN register. Payment never influences this assessment.
Compare nearby
Top-rated roofers in Melbourne
Ranked by AustralianRoofers Trust Score — swipe to compare.












Contact ELR Roofing
Send an enquiry straight to ELR Roofing — it goes only to them, and they reply directly to your email. We never sell your details or add you to a marketing list.
Roofing knowledge base
Guides for homeowners and renovators
Plain-English answers to the most common Australian roofing questions.
