AustralianRoofers Trust Score New
How it's calculated: a transparent, evidence-weighted score — identity & longevity from the public ABN register, reputation from verified Google reviews, and consistency from cross-checking independent platforms. Grades are proportional to the evidence. Where we search the register and can't confirm a business, the identity check scores zero rather than being quietly left out — so a firm we couldn't verify never outranks one we could. Longevity stays unscored in that case, because without a registration date there's nothing to measure.
Our honest take
If a mate in Melbourne's south-east asked us about Holmes Roofing, we'd say this is about as clear-cut as a small roofer's record gets. It holds a flat 5.0 from 50 Google reviews, and in the 20 most recent we read there's a single 4-star — from a happy customer, as it turns out — and nineteen 5s. More telling than the score is how closely the reviews agree with each other: the same man, Carl, inspecting the roof, quoting, turning up on time, doing the work and cleaning up afterwards. Two separate reviewers make the same pointed observation — that, unlike others who quoted, Carl actually came out and looked at the roof before pricing the job.
The work is mostly tile-roof care: restorations with cleaning and repainting, re-bedding and re-pointing of ridge caps, and leak repairs. On its own site the firm says founder Carl Holmes came from Yorkshire, came to Australia to work in the roofing industry, has over 16 years' experience and is fully qualified in slating and tiling. Those are the firm's own claims, as is 'fully insured' — we haven't seen the paperwork. What we did check is the register: Holmes Roofing Pty Ltd is an active Victorian company, ABN 66 659 735 823, registered in May 2022 at a Cranbourne-area postcode. The firm doesn't publish its ABN, so we matched it by name — it's the only active Victorian company called Holmes Roofing Pty Ltd — and it's worth confirming the number on your quote.
The caveats are modest but real. Google is the only place this firm is reviewed — our research found no ProductReview listing — so there's no second source behind the perfect score, and 50 reviews is a decent base rather than a deep one. The company is four years old, so the '16 years' is Carl's trade experience, not the firm's history. And the reviews name nobody but Carl, which is the charm of it but also the limit: one tradesman can only be on one roof at a time, so ask about lead times. One reviewer mentions being given a 10-year guarantee on re-bedding work; that's a customer's account rather than a term published on the firm's site, so get whatever guarantee applies to your job in writing.
Reputation across the web New
The same firm, checked across platforms
Verified business details New
Checked against the public ABN register
Source: verified against the official Australian Business Register via ABN Lookup (abr.business.gov.au), including GST registration.
What they're actually known for New
Ranked by what customers mention — not a self-declared list
Who you'll actually deal with
Carl Holmes — founder, and the man on the roof
The firm's own site names Carl Holmes as founder and says he's originally from Yorkshire, came to Australia to work in the roofing industry, has over 16 years of roofing experience and holds full qualifications in slating and tiling. Those are the firm's claims and we haven't seen the certificates — but the reviews leave no doubt about who does the work. Carl is named in 19 of the 20 most recent Google reviews, credited with inspecting, quoting, doing the job and tidying up, and the business replies to nearly every review.
No other name appears in the reviews we read, so this looks like a genuine owner-operator business: the person who quotes is the person on your roof. That's the appeal, and also the limit — one tradesman can only take on so much, so ask about lead times and whether anyone else will be working on a bigger job. The company behind him, Holmes Roofing Pty Ltd, dates from May 2022, so most of the 16 years the site mentions would predate the company itself.
What clients say
In their own words
Carl was very professional and hard working. Always showed up on time and was the only person who when they quoted got up on the roof to identify exactly what work needed to be done. Our roof looks like a brand new roof has be installed and we can't believe it's the same roof! Highly recommend
We had our roof restored by Holmes Roofing. Carl was punctual, transparent and had good attention to detail. Reasonably priced and available when we needed the work done.
Carl did a great job with our roof repair. Was on time, clear communication about our roof issues and cleaned up well afterwards, would recommend his services for sure
Reviewers describe the same experience again and again: Carl inspects the roof properly before quoting, turns up on time, communicates clearly, does careful restoration and re-pointing work, and cleans up afterwards — at prices several call reasonable or competitive.
Best for
- Tile-roof restorations in Melbourne's south-east and on the Mornington Peninsula — cleaning, re-bedding, re-pointing and repainting are what reviewers praise most
- Homeowners who want the person quoting to be the person doing the work — Carl is named in 19 of the 20 most recent reviews
- Leak repairs and ridge-capping work where a proper look at the roof matters before a price is given
Less suited for
- Metal or Colorbond roofing — the recent reviews are almost entirely about tiled roofs, and the qualifications the firm cites are in slating and tiling
- Homes outside Melbourne's south-east and the Mornington Peninsula, which is the service area the firm gives on its own site
- Anyone wanting a second review platform to cross-check, or a multi-crew company for a large or urgent project — this is an owner-operator reviewed only on Google
Before you commit
Five questions worth asking
- Your ABN isn't on your website — can you confirm it's 66 659 735 823 (Holmes Roofing Pty Ltd) and put it on the quote?
- Your site says you're fully insured and qualified in slating and tiling — can you send me your public liability certificate and any Victorian registration number that applies to a job of my size?
- One reviewer mentions a 10-year guarantee on re-bedding work — what guarantee applies to my job, and will you put it in writing?
- Will you be doing the work yourself, or will anyone else be on the roof — and what's your current lead time?
- For a restoration, what's included step by step — pressure clean, re-bedding, re-pointing, primer and number of coats — and what happens to the price if you find broken tiles once you start?
Bottom line
A four-year-old registered company fronted by an owner-operator who, on the evidence of 50 Google reviews, inspects properly, prices fairly and does tidy tile-roof work across Melbourne's south-east. The gaps are a single review platform and an ABN we matched by name rather than from the firm's own site — confirm the ABN and insurance on your quote, and this looks like a low-risk choice for a restoration or repair.
Assessed by the editorial team at AustralianRoofers.com from public Google Business Profile data, the firm's own website, and the ABN register. Payment never influences this assessment.
Compare nearby
Top-rated roofers in Melbourne
Ranked by AustralianRoofers Trust Score — swipe to compare.












Contact Holmes Roofing Pty Ltd
Send an enquiry straight to Holmes Roofing Pty Ltd — it goes only to them, and they reply directly to your email. We never sell your details or add you to a marketing list.
Roofing knowledge base
Guides for homeowners and renovators
Plain-English answers to the most common Australian roofing questions.
